Two glorious grapes, expression of two distant territories in every sense, both
capable of expressing white wines of indisputable magnificence. The first one
of the two - Fiano - despite it is cultivated in some territories of South
Italy only, has its best expression in Campania, in particular, in the
territory of Avellino. The second one - Riesling - originates from Germany and
it is the indisputable glory of Mosel wines, capable of giving masterpieces of
remarkable class, elegance and finesse. The spreading of Riesling is such that,
today, it is considered an international variety, even cultivated in
territories not perfectly suited to this variety, its fame catches the
attention and dreams of many producers. The spreading of Fiano is certainly
more limited - it can be hardly found outside South Italy - however this is not
an obstacle to its fame and greatness, undeniably one of the most important
varieties of Italy.
Before talking about Riesling, we should clear a confusion concerning another
pretty common variety in Italy - in particular in the northern-eastern areas of
Italy and Oltrepo Pavese - known as Riesling Italico. For the sake of
clearness, it should be said the variety we will cover in this report is
Rhine Riesling, having no connection with the Italian one, also known
as Welschriesling. Not only the two varieties have nothing in common,
even the wines they give are completely different and, in particular, quite
different aging potentials over time. The confusion is however common and
sometimes the two varieties are wrongly believed to be the same. For this
reason, certain producers expressly write Rhine Riesling (Riesling
Renano in Italian) in their labels in order to distinguish it from
Welschriesling. It however must be said that, in general terms, the
simple mention of Riesling refers to Rhine Riesling.
Fiano is one of the many varieties existing since remote times in the Italian
territory and introduced by ancient Greeks. The grape was successful since the
very beginning of its introduction, catching the interest not just of men who
made wine from it. Even insects, bees in particular (ape in Italian),
were attracted by the sweetness of the juice of this variety and, for this
reason, the grape was called vitis apicia. This name was later changed
into Fiano, passing through apina, therefore apiana, then
afiana and finally Fiano. To this variety was even dedicated the
very first place in which vineyards of Fiano were historically planted in:
Lapio, in province of Avellino, was in fact named after this ancient variety.
Even today, Lapio has not lost its very ancient tradition and the cultivation
of Fiano plays a fundamental role, as well as wine production, among the most
significant lands of Fiano di Avellino.
Found all over the territory of Campania, Fiano is also cultivated in
Basilicata, Apulia, Molise and it is also found - although marginally - in
other regions of Italy. The most important land of Fiano is however Campania,
in particular the area of Avellino, the territory which has certainly received
the highest success and attention. It should however be noticed, because of the
huge diversity of the vast territory of Campania, from sandy soils of
coastlines to volcanic soils, Fiano expresses wines with quite different
characters, different one from each other, all however being of remarkable
interest. The composition of soil, the availability of water and micro climate
conditions of soil give in fact very different interpretations of Fiano. For
example, we could consider the finesse and minerality of Fiano di Avellino
compared to the more full and robust interpretations of Cilento, in province of
Salerno.
|
|  |
| The intense color, almost golden yellow, of
Fiano |
|
Germany is the indisputable homeland of Riesling, besides being the land in
which this variety originates from. Moreover, a good expression is also
obtained in Alsace, despite the fact we should notice this variety is
considered international, therefore found in many wine countries of the
world. Riesling is also one of the few white varieties capable of making wines
suited for a long aging in bottle. It is in fact not rare, given the proper
wine making and keeping conditions, a wine produced with Riesling can give its
best even after more than ten years from vintage, a quality not easy to have
with most of white wines. On this regard, we can certainly say most of Riesling
bottles are uncorked while in their youth, without giving them the chance to a
magnificent evolution. For the sake of truth, it should be said not all the
Riesling is made with this goal in mind.
One of the most known characteristics of aged Riesling is the typical smell of
petrol and kerosene. This particular quality of Riesling is very appreciated by
many wine lovers, whereas it can also be considered unpleasing by many
occasional drinkers. Grape of remarkable versatility, Riesling gives
extraordinary dry table wines, as well as late harvest and sweet wines by
using dried grapes. Riesling is also appreciated in the production of the so
called eiswein, wines of extraordinary balance thanks to its
characteristic acidity, nevertheless, having an elegant olfactory and gustatory
profile. Wines of strong crispness, even in their youth are however capable of
giving pleasing emotions, mainly of fruits and flowers, according to the
territory and, in any case, of strong personality.
Fiano and Riesling are capable of making wines with remarkable potentials of
aging, while giving back, after some years, nectars of extraordinary greatness,
although keeping their respective personalities. In our tasting we will compare
two wines produced with Fiano and Riesling in their young condition, in
order to emphasize differences. The study of mature wines produced with these
two varieties certainly is amazing, however not suited for the goal of our
tasting, as we are mainly interested in focusing on differences of the two
grapes in their young condition and not altered by time. On this regard, we
will therefore pick two wines of the same vintage and young, that is
having no more than two years of aging in bottle. It would be better to get a
Riesling from German Mosel, however produced in a cool climate area. As for
Fiano, we will pick a bottle produced in the territory of Avellino.
|
 | |
Riesling, as opposed to Fiano, shows a
paler color with an evident greenish yellow hue | |
|
Let's start the tasting of the two wines from appearance analysis, a phase
universally accepted by the many sensorial evaluation methods as the primary
analysis in a wine. Differences will be evident by a simple observation of the
two glasses, something which will emphasize the diversities in color nuances.
Both wines have a high transparency - a typical characteristic in most of the
whites - and this is the only common quality in the two wines. The color of
Fiano shows, in general terms, a darker hue than Riesling. The famous Italian
grape can in fact show a straw yellow color, even very intense, with nuances of
greenish yellow, whereas Riesling is characterized by a greenish yellow color.
In the German grape will be in fact observed a paler color with evident greenish
nuances, hues which can be observed even in Fiano, although with a lesser
impact.
The olfactory profiles of Fiano and Riesling are very interesting and, despite
both varieties benefit from the evolution of time, even in their young wines is
possible to perceive pleasing and complex aromas. Different olfactory profiles,
they however represent excellent wines and suited for the study of sensorial
tasting. The differences of the two varieties are evident, in particular,
during the evaluation of the opening - that is the aromas perceived at the
first smell and without swirling the glass - however offering common qualities.
The olfactory realm of Fiano and Riesling is mainly represented by aromas
belonging to the family of fruit, nevertheless, it will also be found aromas of
flowers. Finally, it should be noticed the vinification of these two varieties
is mainly made in inert containers, a technique allowing the best aromatic
expression of Fiano and Riesling.
By holding the glass in vertical position and without swirling, let's proceed
with the comparison of olfactory profiles of the two wines, starting from
Fiano. The opening of the great white grape of Campania, gives to the nose
pleasing and intense aromas of apple, pear, peach and plum, as well as
perceptions of hazelnut, this one very typical in wines produced with Fiano
grape. To complete the profile will follow flower aromas of hawthorn and broom.
The opening of Riesling, evaluated by holding the glass still and without
swirling, is characterized by an olfactory profile quite different from Fiano.
From the glass will be mainly perceived aromas recalling citrus fruits, in
particular lemon and cedar, to which are added pleasing aromas of apricot,
peach and apple. Aromas recalling flowers will mainly express broom and
jasmine. Finally, a characteristic pretty common in Riesling is an elegant
mineral touch, a quality which can also be found in Fiano.
Let's proceed with the evaluation of the differences of the two wines by means
of gustatory analysis. At the taste, the attack of Fiano - that is the first
sensation perceived at the very first sip of the wine - is characterized by a
pleasing crispness. It will also be perceived the role of alcohol, that in
wines produced with this variety reaches an appreciable quantity: its
burning effect will tend to balance the pleasing acidity. Fiano has a
good body that, it should be noticed, gets even fuller in case the grape is
cultivated in clay soils. The attack of Riesling too allows the appreciation of
an evident crispness - more accentuated than Fiano - also caused by the fact in
these wines, in particular those made in Germany, the quantity of alcohol is
lower. This characteristic therefore favors the exaltation of acidity. The
structure of Riesling generally is weaker than Fiano, in particular in those
wines produced in cool climate areas, such as Germany.
The final phase of our contrast tasting will try to focus on the differences of
the two wines after having swallowed them. Fiano, a white grape of well known
quality, generally makes wines with a persistent finish and in which can be
mainly perceived flavors of apple, plum and peach, most of the times can also
be perceived its typical sensation of hazelnut. The finish of Riesling, also in
this case, a variety of indisputable quality, is persistent as well and in the
mouth are generally perceived flavors recalling citrus fruits, in particular,
lemon. In this wine can also be perceived flavors of peach, apricot and
tropical fruits, as well as a pleasing sensation of acidity. Two great grapes,
expression of distant lands, capable of making extraordinary wines, with a
remarkable elegance and class, qualities requiring, in any case, the talent of
man and his land.
|